Comparison of Brecht and Commedia dell'arte
Both use exaggerated motions
They use stereotypes rather than fleshed out characters
Reflection: the same methods are used but for similar reasons, but different purposes, for they are used to be very clear and easy to understand, the characters are supposed to be easily recognizable, but the reason for this in Brechts style of theatre is because he does not want the audience relating just recognizing and he wanted a simple story.
In Brechtian theatre scenes stand by themselves, they do not necessarily tell a chronological story and the super objectives of Stanislavsky do not work, although the actors do need to keep track of the message they trying to send. In Brecht's plays he only presents the action, there is no explanation as he not trying to excuse or condemn anyone's actions. Brecht uses a narrator to tell the story so that when the scene is acted out the audience wonders "how" not "what". This way the audience is more concerned about the situation than the characters. Brecht attempts to show the truth from society while Stanislavski tries to show the truth from the characters emotions.
We tried to use what we had learned in some skits. First we tried to do a group of losing soldiers. We used a triangle marching pattern to show the fear of the soldiers (the scared people were in the back and the braver ones were in front). We had some people running, some charging, and some dieing. We discovered that we did not show how we were losing as much as we should have. Then we did one about the management of a big factory giving themselves a raise and refuse to give one to the workers. We were supposed to show how selfish the managers were. When the managers began yelling at the workers we learned that the angrier they got the more scared the workers would get (An inverse ratio).
Truth in Acting
Stanislavski: wants to convey the psychological truth (the emotions of a relatable character)
Brecht: situational truth (eg. bosses are evil and horrible, workers are good) he may use masks for the A-effect and to show the characters better e.g. a pig mask for the boss
Commedia: truth in characters (stereotypes must be relatable)
No comments:
Post a Comment